Should Nuts be Banned from Schools?

Australia Wide First Aid
Select Figure to use


amelieA heated debate has been sparked after a photograph of a 5 year old girl who suffered an allergic reaction on her first day of school was posted to social media. The photograph has received a mixed response from the public, ranging from support to criticism.

Amelie King’s first day of school didn’t go as her parents hoped. Her mother Joanne King was called to pick Amelie up early after she was exposed to peanuts and had an allergic reaction.

Joanne went down to the school immediately and when she realised Amelie was improving she brought her home and called the ambulance, following up with a visit to the GP.

She says "Fortunately for Amelie her reaction was only mild. But I have heard ... of far more severe [reactions], even just through sniffing peanuts."

Amelie has had anaphylaxis since she was a baby and her parents have actively reinforced the importance of avoiding her allergens.

"We absolutely hound into her the sort of vigilance she has to learn to have, and the strategies she needs to have on how to manage it. But unfortunately we also rely on the safety of the community as well."

Unfortunately, Amelie’s reaction can be set off by just touching traces of nuts. On Monday her reaction was a result of playing with a friend who wasn’t even eating nuts at the time, but had traces on her hands or clothes.

In a bid to raise awareness of the dangers of anaphylaxis, Joanne posted a photograph of Amelie’s reaction on Facebook. In the post she challenged parents to think about the consequences of allowing their child to take a potentially dangerous snack into the playground.

Joanne wrote:

"Should a parent have to fear their child dying on the first day of school?"

"A simple sharing of pencils or a game of ring-a-rosy is all you need to pass on the nut oil."

"This message is from one of those annoying parents of a child with anaphylaxis, because I don't want my child to die."

The photograph has reached thousands of people and is receiving mixed responses. Some parents think it is unfair that their child should miss out on a healthy and nutritious snack just because it might be dangerous to another child, while others completely support Joanne.

Amelie’s father, Matt, says that the ban could be a good idea for younger children around the age of 5 who aren’t as capable of protecting themselves.

"Once they're a little bit older obviously you can't do that entirely and control the situations that they're in but they do become more aware when they're a bit older and a bit more responsible," Matt said.

"We're not going to say don't give your kids these things but just maybe don't send them to school with them.”

Although a nut ban restricts lunch box favourites such as peanut butter, Nutella and cookies with nuts in them, Joanne says there are plenty of fantastic alternatives parents can give their children and they can always eat these things outside of school.

What are your thoughts on a nut ban in schools? Is it too controlled or is it worth protecting young children who could have a fatal reaction to nuts?

More articles

Pregnant Woman with Asthma Inhaler Asthma and Pregnancy
World Allergy WeekWorld Allergy Week
Goodwill bridge in BrisbaneWinter First Aid Tips for Asthma Sufferers
Dentist making local anaesthesia shot before surgery. Senior woman at dental clinic. Dentist with assistant install implant in a patient mouth in modern dental officeAnaphylaxis and Anesthesia
Group ExerciseAsthma and Exercise
Girl Allergic Reaction to FoodAnaphylaxis and Food Allergies
Blood Pressure Reading Anaphylaxis and Hypotension
auto-injector pen applied to the thighAsthma & Anaphylaxis Emergency First Aid
Desktop spirometry used to diagnose asthma and other breathing conditionsAsthma management
Pet Allergy Concept. Ill black girl sneezing and holding paper napkin, suffering from runny nose and nasal congestion, sitting on couch at home indoors in blurred background, selective focus on dogCommon Causes of Allergies

Recently published

Infographic on How to Beat Depression in Men What is Male Depression?
Infographic on Common Triggers of Depression 15 Common Triggers of Depression
Infographic on 20 ways to beat mental stress20 Ways to Beat Mental Stress
Infographic of First Aid for Scarlet FeverFirst Aid for Scarlet Fever
Infographic on Heart, Stroke, and Vascular DiseasesHeart, Stroke & Vascular Diseases Statistics
Infographic on What is Foot and Mouth DiseaseFast Facts about Foot and Mouth Disease
bee-sting-chart-coverFirst Aid Chart for Bee Sting
Infographic on Different Types of Stroke Rehabilitation Life After a Stroke: Rehabilitation and Recovery
Infographic on New Geelong Training CentreWe Have a New Geelong Training Location
Infographic on Differences between Strokes and Seizures Is it a Stroke or a Seizure?